E-Newsletter July 2009 #1

Here is your update on TACA (Talk About Curing Autism). If you are new to our site... WELCOME! This newsletter is produced two to four times each month.

We are an autism education and support group. We want to make this e-newsletter informative for you. As always, contact us your thoughts and/or questions so we can improve it.

We focus on parent information and support, parent mentoring, dietary intervention, the latest in medical research, special education law, reviews of the latest treatments, and many other topics relating to autism. Our main goal is to build our community so we can connect, share and support each other.

Talk About Curing Autism (TACA) provides general information of interest to the autism community. The information comes from a variety of sources and TACA does not independently verify any of it. The views expressed herein are not necessarily TACA’s.

In this edition:

TACA News

1.  Find a TACA Meeting

2.  1st Annual TACA Hawaii Family Picnic!

3.   Join us for Coffee Talk!

4.  New Parent Seminar

General News

5.  Daily Autism Updates for Families

6.  Health Care Reform that Fails to Stop Autism Insurance Discrimination is Unacceptable—TACA Needs Your Help!

7.  Action Alert! 19 States Have Zero Regulations Protecting Disabled Children in Schools!

8.  Federal Ban Sought On Student Restraint

9.  “Tidal Wave” of Young Adults with Autism about to Flood Cash-Strapped California

10. Court says public must pay for private special ed

11. Vitamin D-3’s Role in Fighting ADHD and Autism

Vaccine News

12. Legislation Introduced to Require First Comparative Study of Vaccinated vs. Unvaccinated Populations

13. Autism and Toxins, Response to Dr. Harvey Karp

14. Julia's Journey

15. Medical Report of MMR-enduced Encephalitis from 1973

16. Growing Divide Among Courts On Vaccines

[go to home page]    

1 Find a TACA Meeting
Come to a TACA Meeting!

TACA holds monthly meetings in many locations throughout the United States that feature educational speakers on important topics and allow family members to connect with one another and stay on top of the latest information in the autism world. Each TACA group maintains a resource library of the latest autism books and tapes that can be checked out by members at no charge.

Check out our group listings: each contains information on TACA meetings and special events as well as a contact form.

Are you wondering what happens at a TACA meeting? Watch our video.

 
2 1st Annual TACA Hawaii Family Picnic!
Sunday, July 26, 2009

This extremely popular family event will be attended by Hawaii families
who have children with autism. This is TACA of Hawaii's first annual event!

 
3 Join us for Coffee Talk!

Coffee Talk for Parents:
Come and receive some extra support or to chat all topics related to autism and meet other TACA families at these informal, monthly get-togethers.

Bakersfield, CA
Inland Empire, CA
Orange County, CA
Glen Burnie, MD
Gaithersburg, MD
Hamilton, NJ
Las Vegas, NV
Henderson, NV

Corporate Coffee Talk
TACA Headquarters, July 14, 2009

Local businesses are invited to take a coffee break with us to learn about partnering with TACA to help families

More information

 
4 New Parent Seminar
Naperville, IL
Saturday, July 18, 2009, 8:30 a.m.-5 p.m.

After receiving the diagnosis of autism for a beloved child (or children), parents typically struggle as they search through various resources to locate information needed to help their child the fastest. The goal of the one-day New Parent Orientation is to provide parents and caretakers the “jump start” they need at the beginning of their journey from parents who have “been there, done that.” In addition to sage advice, parents who attend will receive: an overview of beginning therapies and biomedical intervention, where to go for what information, and recommended first steps. The seminar will be given by experienced parents who volunteer their time in providing the education new parents need.

Who should Attend?
This one-day seminar is geared for parents and caretakers of children affected by autism. Content will be provided in an “overview” presentation with web and book resource information for additional details. This seminar is geared to parents and caretakers new to the autism journey (less than 18 months) who have not yet started a behavioral/educational program or biomedical testing and interventions.

Register Online

 
5 Daily Autism Updates for Families

All news related to autism:  

For daily updates to all autism legislative issues: ChangeforAutism.org

AgeofAutism.com
 
6 Health Care Reform that Fails to Stop Autism Insurance Discrimination is Unacceptable—TACA Needs Your Help!

Like it or not, health care reform is coming to America. President Obama has pledged that the Health Care Reform Bill that is currently working its way through Congress will be signed into law by October of this year.  The autism community needs to unite and take advantage of this unique opportunity to stop autism insurance discrimination.

Why is this important now?

Autism insurance reform can and should be included in the final health care reform bill. For this to happen, the autism community needs to mobilize now! Congress ends its summer legislative session on August 3rd. That gives our community under a month to make this goal happen.

Television commercials on CNN, CNBC, and MSNBC will be running over the next few days bringing this critical issue to the forefront of our country. These ads start running today. We need to capitalize on the visibility of these commercials and make autism insurance reform a reality.

How you can help

Contact Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi and Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid.

Please use these numbers.

Washington DC offices:
Speaker Pelosi: 202-225-0100
Majority Leader Reid’s: 202-224-3542

West Coast offices (for those calling after 2 p.m. Pacific Standard Time):
Speaker Pelosi: 415-556-4862
Majority Leader Reid: 775-882-7343

Need help with what to say on the phone? Use the following message, if you like:

“Hi, my name is ___________________. I am calling from _____________ (city), _______________________ (state).  I want you to know that health care reform that does not stop autism insurance discrimination is completely and totally unacceptable. People with autism deserve coverage for the treatments and therapies that will help their medical condition. Thank you.”

Please be courteous and respectful but firm. Be patient and keep dialing until you get through. And once you get through, keep calling. 

Advocacy tip of the day

Remember that you can multiply your efforts when you think outside the box. The people who call do not need to have a child with autism. They need to care about this issue and be willing to make two phone calls a day until the issue is resolved. TACA challenges everyone to find 10 people you know (family, neighbors, coworkers, teachers, aides, therapists, etc.) who will be willing to do this to help your child, and all children in the United States with autism.

Let’s exercise our right as Americans to be heard by our elected officials and make Autism Insurance Discrimination a thing of the past.

 
7 Action Alert! 19 States Have Zero Regulations Protecting Disabled Children in Schools!
States that do have regulations or guidelines are not being followed by many school districts! Our federal lawmakers say they have not heard from us on harmful restraint and seclusion!!

According to a May 2009 government report on restraint and seclusion practices, an overwhelming amount of abuse, neglect, and emotional abuse is happening in schools throughout the country.

  • THE REPORT FOUND NO FEDERAL LAWS IN PLACE THAT REGULATE RESTRAINT & SECLUSION 

  • THE REPORT REVEALED THAT STATE REGULATIONS ARE “WIDELY DIVERGENT” AND THAT 19 STATES HAVE NOTHING THAT REGULATE RESTRAINT & SECLUSION IN SCHOOLS
  • THE REPORT REVEALED TEN CASE STUDIES WHERE CHILDREN WITH VARYING DISABILITIES DIED AS A RESULT OF RESTRAINT AND SECLUSION, WERE SERIOUSLY HARMED, OR EMOTIONALLY TRAUMATIZED 
  • BECAUSE THERE ARE NO LAWS, MANY OF THE PEOPLE RESPONSIBLE FOR THIS ABUSE STILL WORK WITHIN THE SCHOOL SYSTEMS

Take these two steps immediately to raise your voice and help our children's safety become a government priority!

STEP 1 SEND A LETTER TO FEDERAL LAWMAKERS & CALL: every member on the Education and Labor Committee needs to hear from us IMMEDIATELY. CLICK HERE for a sample letter and list of committee members. We need to show them how big our voices are!

STEP 2 SEND A LETTER TO STATE LAWMAKERS & CALL: if you are in the following states, you have NO state regulations: Wisconsin, Wyoming, Vermont, South Carolina, South Dakota, North Dakota, Oklahoma, New Jersey, Nebraska, Mississippi, Missouri, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Indiana, Idaho, Florida, Georgia, Arizona.  CLICK HERE for a sample letter and a link to find your state reps. For people in the other states, most of your laws aren't being consistently followed.  PLEASE SEND LETTERS TO BOTH COMMITTEE MEMBERS AND STATE LAWMAKERS AND ALSO SEND A COPY TO KUTZG@GAO.GOV.

IT'S VERY IMPORTANT THEY HEAR US ON THIS IMMEDIATELY!!!

Signed, The National Autism Association
Autism Research Institute
Talk About Curing Autism
Unlocking Autism
Autism One
The Autism Human Rights and Discrimination Initiative
The Autism Trust
Autism Action Network
Schafer Autism Report
Parents in Action, PIA, Inc.
Concerned Parents in Florida of Children with ASD
Families Against Restraint and Seclusion
Autism Salutes

What you can also do right now to help protect your child:

Visit www.nationalautism.org or www.aprais.tash.org

Download a sample "no-consent" letter to provide to your child's teachers, principals or have placed in your child's IEP. For more information, visit:
http://familiesagainstrestraintandseclusion.blogspot.com

Take Action Today! Go to: nationalautismassociation.org/abuse.php

 
8 Federal Ban Sought On Student Restraint
Wall Street Journal

By ROBERT TOMSHO

Educators' use of restraint holds and other methods to subdue students they deem disruptive has been blamed for injury or death of many students in recent years. Now groups are pushing for a federal ban on certain tactics.

The Old Quiet Room, no longer in use, at Ashland Middle School in Ashland, Wis. Places such as this have been used to control students.
Properly done, restraint involves using precise holds, often with the hands or arms, to subdue and calm someone. Students in such circumstances -- many of which have learning disabilities such as autism and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder -- also are sometimes put in so-called seclusion rooms.

Although there are no nationwide data on the use of such measures, they have attracted greater attention in recent years as more students with behavioral disabilities are being educated in mainstream schools where there is greater public scrutiny and many educators have little related training. Although some situations have been the result of threatening behavior by such students in classrooms or hallways, researchers say many incidents don't appear to have involved children who were aggressive.

In a report last month, the Government Accountability Office said it found hundreds of allegations of school-related "death and abuse" since 1990, the vast majority involving children with disabilities. The cases included a Florida teacher's aide who gagged and duct-taped children as young as 6 for misbehaving and a 14-year-old in Texas who refused to stay seated in class and died after a 230-pound teacher tried to restrain him by lying on top of him on the floor. In Texas alone, the GAO said more than 4,200 students were restrained nearly 19,000 times during the 2007-08 school year.

In January, a report by the National Disability Rights Network, a system of federally mandated legal-advocacy organizations, detailed dozens of similar cases. Such groups have been in the forefront of the debate because children with disabilities are so often involved.

Some want a federal ban on tactics such as restraints of prone students that can imperil breathing. "We think they have to be tightly controlled at the federal level," said Barbara Trader, executive director of Tash, an advocacy group for people with disabilities.

But Bruce Hunter, associate executive director of the American Association of School Administrators, said it is sometimes an educator's duty to try to restrain a student. "You can't sit and call the cops and watch," he said.

The federal government already regulates the use of restraint and seclusion in hospitals and other facilities that it helps to fund. In psychiatric hospitals, for instance, only licensed medical personnel can order that a patient be restrained or put into a locked room.

But there are no related federal laws covering schools, and state regulations -- where they exist -- vary widely. According to the GAO, seven states restrict the use of restraints but not seclusion; 19 states have no restraint or seclusion laws. "The one place where our kids spend the most time is the place where they have the least protection," says Rocky Nichols, executive director of the Disability Rights Center of Kansas, a legal-advocacy group.

In Washington, the effort to limit the use of such techniques is being championed by Rep. George Miller, chairman of the House Committee on Education and Labor. In January, the California Democrat called for the GAO review, and last month his committee held hearings. What was discovered, he said in an interview, is a system "in which children are unnecessarily dying and being harmed."

In testimony before Congress in May, Education Secretary Arne Duncan called such findings "disturbing" and said he is instructing chief school officers in all 50 states to detail their plans for keeping students safe. Several dozen advocacy groups subsequently discussed the issue in a meeting with White House staff.

Phyllis Musumeci, founder of a group called Florida Families Against Restraint and Seclusion, said federal oversight is critical. "These are children, not apples and oranges," said Ms. Musumeci, who says her son was restrained 89 times during a 14-month period in middle school. "We need to all be working off the same law."

The scope of any possible federal law is still uncertain. Mr. Miller and others involved in the discussions say they would like it to be crafted so that states are primarily responsible for developing and enforcing policies. One possible model is a bill Mr. Miller sponsored last year that was focused on preventing child abuse at residential treatment facilities. It would require states to develop such policies involving those settings and establish a federal system for evaluating reports of abuse. The House has passed the bill but it has yet to be taken up in the Senate.

Write to Robert Tomsho at rob.tomsho@wsj.com

 
9 “Tidal Wave” of Young Adults with Autism about to Flood Cash-Strapped California
Age of Autism

By David Kirby

Broke California will begin the new decade with crushing debt and wholesale elimination of human services. Meanwhile, President Obama has rankled Congressional Democrats with plans to earmark millions of dollars in NIH funds to find the causes and cures of autism.

Are these two things related? You bet they are.

Barack Obama is not a stupid man. He sees the budgetary train wreck hurtling down the track towards the US Treasury. His Administration knows that the number of adults with autism in this country is about to explode. Parents can’t foot the bill, so taxpayers will have to. The price tag will be stratospherical.

Isn’t it better to earmark millions in autism research funds right now for NIH to identify the causes of autism – despite outcries from Rep. Obey, Sen. Harkin and others – in order to save hundreds of billions further down the road?

It’s called frontloading the budget, and if we don’t do it, the coming army of young adults with autism will march in and break the bank.

Anyone who thinks that a lot of people with autism somehow “grow out of their disorder” by adulthood should take a look at an important article published today in the Sacramento Bee. (HERE)

Here, you will meet California residents such as Marlon Barton, a 6’2”, 283-pound “strapping young man who flaps his hands and makes odd noises,” according to reporter Cynthia Hubert. “No one knows quite what to do with him,” she says.

Marlon Barton is 26 years old and “acutely” autistic. He scares people. My heart goes out to him, and to his amazing mother.

But they are hardly alone.

“As a tidal wave of these youngsters moves toward adulthood with complex behavioral and medical problems, society is largely unprepared,” Hubert writes. “The futures of hundreds of thousands of autistic people in America cannot be ignored for long.”

Dr. Robert Hendren, director of the UC Davis M.I.N.D. Institute, concurs. "We don't have the programs. We don't have the research," he warns. "We have this very large adult population of autistics coming along, and we don't know how to deal with them. We just haven't come to terms with it."

California has certainly not come to terms with it – and I have no idea what will happen to the thousands of young people in need who will be showing up at state offices in the next few years, their parents desperately seeking services.

Currently, 81.7% of all autism cases in the state Department of Development Services system are under 18, but that ratio is about to change fast. (see graph above)

There are now 6,300 adult Californians receiving autism services through DDS. But over the next four years, more than 4,000 teenagers will join their ranks. By 2018, the total number of adults with autism will more than triple, to 19,000 people -- each requiring tens of thousands of dollars (or more) in care, education and support services, every year.

California cannot afford it.

Which brings us back to President Obama. By 2023, the US will have some 380,000 people who will need “extensive adult services,” at the cost of billions of dollars a year, Hubert writes. “Care providers are just beginning to grapple with how to deal with the surge, even as governments slash social services to cope with budget deficits.”

Anyone still trying to lull Americans into complacently believing that autism is a genetic disorder that has always been with us in such staggering numbers (we just never noticed before) needs to stop doing that. Now.

It’s time to stop pretending this isn’t happening.

Autism’s toll on children, families, friends and caregivers has been devastating. President Obama knows that the disorder will now exact its toll on taxpayers. I am encouraged that Federal health officials are finally moving to identify all possible environmental autism triggers – including vaccines – so we can finally learn how to slow this spigot down. (HERE)

Why not spend money now to find the causes and cures for autism? If we don’t, that tidal wave will just keep on washing over us.

David Kirby is author of Evidence of Harm, a founding contributor to Huffington Post and a contributor to Age of Autism. His next book, “ANIMAL FACTORY” – about the impact of industrial livestock production on our health and the environment – will be released within the year.

 
10 Court says public must pay for private special ed
By JESSE J. HOLLAND – Jun 22, 2009

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court has ruled that parents of special education students who opt for private school instead of trying the public system cannot be barred from seeking public reimbursement for their tuition costs.
The court ruled 6-3 Monday in favor of a teenage boy from Oregon whose parents sought to force their local public school district to pay the $5,200 a month it cost to send their son to a private school.

Federal law calls for school districts to reimburse students or their families for education costs when public schools do not have services that address or fulfill the students' needs. Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, the nation's special education students are entitled to a "free and appropriate public education."
Schools have argued that the law says parents of special education students must give public special education programs a chance before seeking reimbursement for private school tuition.

But advocacy groups and parents of some special education students contend that forcing them to try public schools first could force children, especially poor ones, to spend time in an undesirable situation before getting the help they need.

Justice John Paul Stevens said in his majority opinion that the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act requires a school district to pay for private special ed services if the public school doesn't have appropriate services.

"We conclude that IDEA authorizes reimbursement for the cost of special education services when a school district fails to provide a FAPE and the private-school placement is appropriate, regardless of whether the child previously received special education or related services through the public school," Stevens said.

In the case before the Supreme Court, the family of a teenage Oregon boy diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder — who was identified only as T.A. — sued the school district, saying the school did not properly address the student's learning problems. The family is seeking reimbursement for the student's tuition, which cost $5,200 a month. The family paid a total of $65,000 in private tuition.

In its appeal, the Forest Grove School District said students should be forced to at least give public special education programs a try before seeking reimbursement for private tuition. If not, parents would bypass public schools and go directly to private school — and then ask for reimbursement from school systems already burdened by ever-increasing costs.

The court's decision does not require reimbursement, but Stevens said school officials "must consider all relevant factors, including the notice provided by parents and the school district's opportunities for evaluating the child, in determining whether reimbursement for some or all of the cost of the child's private school education is warranted."

Justice David Souter, Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas dissented.

"Given the burden of private school placement, it makes good sense to require parents to try to devise a satisfactory alternative within the public schools," Souter said in the dissent.

This is the court's second attempt at resolving this issue. The high court split 4-4 on a similar case from New York City two years ago. Justice Anthony Kennedy recused himself in the New York case but was among those who ruled on the Oregon case.

Nationwide, the number of special education students placed in private schools at public expense has not changed significantly over the last two decades, Justice Department lawyers said, citing statistics from the U.S. Department of Education. Just under 67,000 pupils were in private placements in 2007 — just 1.1 percent of the country's nearly 6 million special education students.

The case is Forest Grove School District v. T.A., 08-305.

 
11 Vitamin D-3’s Role in Fighting ADHD and Autism
An avalanche of studies released during the past few months emphasizes the importance of vitamin D in maintaining health. The vitamin's benefits cover a wide range of health issues, including neurological disease (Parkinson’s and Alzheimer’s), heart disease, diabetes, and many others. For more information on the importance of vitamin D, read my special report “Vitamin D’s Hidden Role in Your Health.”

Vitamin D also appears to have a role in combating attention deficit hyperactive disorder (ADHD) and autism. More than 4.4 million children have been diagnosed with ADHD. Health officials believe the incidence of autism is 1 in 150. The incidence among boys is even higher: 1 in 94.

Vitamin D’s role in the development of the brain begins when the human brain undergoes its most rapid and complex formation between the last trimester of pregnancy and the first two years of life. In studies of the development of rat brains, which are very similar to humans in terms of vitamin D-3 (the most effective form of vitamin D), vitamin D-3 deficiencies have their most devastating effects during the last trimester of pregnancy.

Studies on rats showed that feeding pregnant rats a diet deficient in vitamin D-3 led to behavioral problems when the offspring grew up. This manifested mainly as high excitability, something we see in ADHD and autism.

Vitamin D-3 deficiency in pregnant animals also has been shown to negatively impact the brain in the offspring in the following ways:

Shrinking of the brain was observed
Abnormal levels of brain growth factors occurred
Formation of abnormal neurons occurred
One effect of vitamin D-3 deficiency during pregnancy is the appearance of an excess number of brain cells, which is characteristic of autistic brains.

Further connections to autism include a state of hypersensitivity that causes the brains of babies whose mothers are deficient in vitamin D-3 to be oversensitive to the harmful effects of multiple vaccinations and infections.

Under today’s vaccine recommendations, children receive 36 vaccines by age 2, a period when the brain is most sensitive to such injury. A vitamin D-3 deficiency makes their brains even more susceptible to damage.

The brain’s immune cell, which is called the microglia contains a number of vitamin D-3 receptors. Newer studies indicate that these receptors play an important role in reducing the damaging reactions vaccines trigger, as well as other toxins such as mercury.

Vitamin D-3 has been shown to significantly soothe activated, angry microglial cells, thus calming the brain’s hypersensitivity.

Recent studies have found widespread, prolonged microglial activation in the brains of autistic individuals lasting from age 3 to 45. This means that their brains are inflamed for very long periods, even decades. Vaccines can produce this reaction, especially in the face of vitamin D-3 deficiency.

It would be interesting to know the incidence of vitamin D-3 deficiencies during pregnancy in mothers of autistic children.

One study found that vaccination impaired the functioning of vitamin D-3. Interestingly, autism is more common in blacks than whites. Dark-skinned people are especially prone to vitamin D-3 deficiency because they cannot absorb as much sunlight.

In essence, it may be that a maternal vitamin D-3 deficiency sets the stage for autism. When combined with the right genetic propensity, which is linked to a high risk of autoimmune disorders, activating an immune reaction in the brain may trigger the effects on brain development associated with autism.

Food additives also have been linked to ADHD and autism. For information, go here to read my special report “Food Additives: What You Eat Can Kill You.”

Dr. Tim Brown, D.C.

Director of Product Innovation,
Design and Development
drbrowndesigns.com

 
12 Legislation Introduced to Require First Comparative Study of Vaccinated vs. Unvaccinated Populations
WASHINGTON, DC – Reps. Carolyn Maloney (D-NY) and Christopher Smith (R-NJ) have introduced the “Comprehensive Comparative Study of Vaccinated and Unvaccinated Populations Act of 2009,” HR 3069, legislation that would require the Secretary of Health and Human Services to conduct a comprehensive, peer-reviewed, comparative study of vaccinated and unvaccinated populations, which has never before been completed.
 
“Vaccines have been instrumental in reducing the incidence of many once-common diseases, but we owe it to parents and children to study and resolve the questions that have arisen over the possible link between vaccines and neurological disorders,” said Maloney. “What is ultimately needed to resolve this issue is a comprehensive national study comparing outcomes between vaccinated and unvaccinated children.  As the most scientifically advanced country in the world, we should be jumping at the chance to resolve the questions that have been raised.  Parents deserve answers, and children deserve no less than absolute certainty and safety.”
 
“Vaccines have been a truly revolutionary contribution to global public health that I have strongly supported. At the same time, it would be unconscionable if we did not fully investigate every aspect of vaccine safety, including varying vaccines schedules, to ensure that individuals were not being exposed to unnecessary risks,” said Smith. “This study would explore critical questions about our children’s health. Only a comprehensive, national examination of data that contrasts vaccinated children to unvaccinated children will answer some of the questions many if not all parents have about the safety of the vaccines we give our children. Congresswoman Maloney and I feel strongly that this will add greatly to the body of knowledge for the healthcare community and the public.”

Other original cosponsors of the bill include Rep. Bart Gordon (D-TN), Chair of the House Science and Technology Committee, and Reps. Dan Burton (R-IN), Patrick Kennedy (D-RI), Jim Langevin (D-RI), Virginia Brown-Waite (R-FL), and Grace Napolitano (D-CA).
 
 Background: Maloney and Smith have also introduced legislation (H.R. 2618) that would improve the current system for vaccine safety monitoring in this country by assigning responsibility for the nation’s vaccine safety to an independent agency within the Department of Health and Human Services; and another (H.R. 2617) that puts in statute definite timelines for the elimination of mercury from vaccines.
 
Maloney introduced similar legislation in the 110th Congress.  Click here for more information.
 
13 Autism and Toxins, Response to Dr. Harvey Karp
Dr. Harvey Karp has just written an excellent blog beginning to discuss the role environmental toxins play in causing autism. I agree that the huge rise in autism is real, and not just related to better diagnosis or reclassification of mental illness. Autism is most likely caused by a genetic predisposition and an environmental "trigger."

 Studies showing that vaccines and their many constituents do not contribute to this problem are flawed, filled with specious reasoning and, for the most part funded by the pharmaceutical industry. Even articles in reputable medical journals are often written by doctors with an economic interest in continuing the vaccination program's status quo. This does not invalidate all of these studies but it certainly makes them suspect and a poor foundation for an argument excluding vaccines from the list of environmental influences on the increase in autism in America and elsewhere.
 
 The facile dismissal of those of us calling for safer vaccinations and scrutiny of the current vaccine schedule is not scientifically based and polarizes the discussion. Perhaps most importantly, this dismissal is insulting to the thousands of parents and families who aver that their children have been harmed by vaccines. There are extremists choosing to ignore the facts in all vaccine/autism camps. I am not one of them.
 
 Asking that cars be manufactured with more attention to safety and that driving is best when done safely does not make one "anti-car" or anti-driving. Asking for safer vaccinations and more judicious use of those we have does not make me or anyone else "anti-vaccine."
 
 The studies Dr. Karp cites show pretty much the opposite of what he's claiming they do. The opposite. The Danish Study's data are misused by all and interpreted to suit one's needs. The Japanese study also shows a connection between the MMR split into three components and autism. Mainstream medical journals rarely will publish editorial comment impugning the quality or integrity of vaccines because they are dependent upon the good graces of the pharmaceutical industry for their publishing dollars. Seeking out reputable commentators is difficult because the extremists on both sides of this debate exaggerate their claims and speak louder and more unpleasantly as if this helps to make their points.
 
 In April of 2009, the Journal of the American Medical Association spoke to the conflict of interest and possible corruption as the journals, the AMA, the AAP and other medical associations rely on money from the manufacturers of vaccines and other drugs.
 
 I have been in practice thirty years. and watched thousands of children get shots, not get shots, develop autism or remain developmentally "neurotypical." I have no proof that vaccines cause autism and would be very excited to have my large group of extremely healthy mostly unvaccinated children studied someday. It would be disingenuous to imply that non-vaccination might not lead to an increased incidence in vaccine-preventable illness. It would be equally disingenuous to state that this possibility poses a great threat to America's children. The risks of vaccinating the way we do now exceeds the benefits of this vaccine program. "Scientists" who suggest that experienced doctors ignore their eyes and ears are wrong. Detractors who say that we should ignore parents who are certain that vaccines caused their children's autism are wrong and often quite mean-spirited.
 
 Dr. Karp, if you are going to talk and blog about kitchen cleaners, furniture polish, pesticides and other toxins, how can you possibly ignore the 30-40 injections of potentially risky material we give children in their first 24 months of life? There is absolutely no proof that these shots are as safe the makers say they are and certainly no proof that new combinations of vaccines and hastily created shots are safe enough for our children.
 
 Certain childhood illnesses are far less common than before we had vaccines to decrease their numbers. When numbers drop so low for certain illnesses, we have to cast a strong critical eye on the possible side effects of a vaccine. This loving, reasonable principle can initially be applied by an individual parent to an individual child and family. We certainly have to add public health into this complicated calculus of risk versus reward. It remains very possible that changing the way we manufacture vaccines and being more selective in our use of them may have huge public health benefits. It would be unscientific and immoral to ignore these more difficult possibilities in favor of the easier answers in Dr. Karp's post. We can save more children if just think harder.
 
 Giving children the chicken pox vaccine may lead to huge shingles problems in adults.
 
 Autism is triggered by many environmental, infectious and other causes. Vaccines are one of these triggers. Believe the parents!

Best,
 
Jay Gordon, MD FAAP

 
14 Julia's Journey
Julia was born a healthy baby on 12-28-05. She was a delight to her family and friends. On January 5th, 2007, one week after her 1st birthday, our family's lives changed forever. Julia (unknowingly to her family) had been seizing in her crib most of the night, was transported to the nearest ER for stabilization, and then airlifted to Miami Children's hospital, where she stayed in PICU and the neurology ward for close to one month. Her diagnosis? Encephalitis (inflammation of her brain) most likely attributed to the MMR-V (measles, mumps, reubella, chicken pox) vaccine she had received nine days previously. When Julia left the hospital, she was functioning at a two month level. She was (and in some respects still is)globally delayed and with significant left sided hemiplegia. It has been over two years since her MMR-V induced encephalitis, and Julia has come a long way, but has a very long way to go.

Friday, June 12, 2009
AMAZING DAY! A MIRACLE HAS HAPPENED!

JULIA WON HER LAWSUIT WITH THE VACCINE INJURY COMPENSATION PROGRAM! THE GOVERNMENT CONCEDED! This means that they agreed that the MMR vaccine caused her encephalitis and resultant brain damage (I mean Marvelous Mind - right Howard!!). This is such a huge, huge, huge help for Julia and my family. The government will reimburse all of her past medical expenses (to her, not to us, which I find a little odd, but OK!) and will pay for all future medical expenses that she incurs from her vaccine injury. I will update as I find out more. Her attorney (Ron Homer and/or Kevin Conway) will be flying out here this summer to evaluate her and her needs with a "life planner" to try to determine what her needs will be. This is HUGE! HUGE! The VICP rarely concedes.....almost never......but they did for her! AMAZING!

Saturday, June 13, 2009
Interesting article...I had been thinking many of these exact things after Julia's last neuro appointment when her dr said she had signs of autism. I didn't want that "word" in her records until Julia's case was decided.

Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. and David Kirby - Vaccine Court: Autism Debate Continues
 
But last week, the parents of yet another child with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) were awarded a lump sum of more than $810,000 (plus an estimated $30-40,000 per year for autism services and care) in compensation by the Court, which ruled that the measels-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine had caused acute brain damage that led to his autism spectrum disorder.

The family of 10-year-old Bailey Banks won their case quietly and without fanfare in June of 2007, but the ruling has only now come to public attention. In the remarkably clear and eloquent decision, Special Master Richard Abell ruled that the Banks had successfully demonstrated that "the MMR vaccine at issue actually caused the conditions from which Bailey suffered and continues to suffer."

Bailey's diagnosis is Pervasive Developmental Disorder -- Not Otherwise Specified (PDD-NOS) which has been recognized as an autism spectrum disorder by CDC, HRSA and the other federal health agencies since at least the 1990s.

In his conclusion, Special Master Abell ruled that Petitioners had proven that the MMR had directly caused a brain inflammation illness called acute disseminated encephalomyelitis (ADEM) which, in turn, had caused the autism spectrum disorder PDD-NOS in the child. Read more.

 
15 Medical Report of MMR-enduced Encephalitis from 1973
Dear David Kirby:
  
Study #7 would be of best research for what I experienced during MMR vaccination at age 1.  Attached file is scanned copy of medical report of result from vaccination.  I would appreciate feedback and possible legal directions possible upon this result.  Thanks you for all research!

Sincerely, Thomas Hoffman
(Minneapolis, MN, seizures and AS dxed)

 
16 Growing Divide Among Courts On Vaccines
CBS Investigates: Federal Court Decides Boy Vaccinated At 8 Weeks Eligible For Compensation
By Sharyl Attkisson

(CBS) The National Law Journal recently reported on a DPT (diphtheria, whole-cell pertussis, tetanus) vaccine case that was reversed on appeal, reports CBS News investigative correspondent Sharyl Attkisson.

The Federal Circuit Court decided that a boy vaccinated at 8 weeks is entitled to compensation, after all.

According to the claim, the vaccination caused a seizure disorder that led to the child, Enrique Andreu, developing a low IQ and language and developmental delays. The Appeals Court (Federal Circuit Court) decided the Special Master (Judge) in the original decision “erroneously… determined that the testimony of Petitioner's physicians was insufficient to establish ‘a logical sequence of cause and effect’ leading to Petitioner's vaccine-related injury; and (erroneously) imposed upon Petitioner an elevated evidentiary burden, requiring conclusive proof in the medical literature linking Petitioner's symptoms to the vaccine at issue.”

In plain language, the Appeals Court sent a message to the Special Masters in Vaccine Court: that they are (at times) interpreting the evidence too harshly against the Plaintiff. In the words of the Plaintiff’s attorney: the Special Masters “require a burden of proof that’s just too high.” The government which defended the case has not made comment. It’s not the first time the Appeals Court has sent such a message to the Vaccine Court. Yet sources say the Appeals Court has not given blanket guidance to the Vaccine Court to help it come into synch with the Appeals Court interpretations and philosophy. If the Vaccine Court’s burden of proof is too high, then what should it be? Where is the bar set?

With those questions yet unanswered, some observers believe reversals such as in the Andreu case could have implications in the autism test cases currently on appeal. The plaintiffs lost three autism test cases soundly in Vaccine Court and all are under appeal. The same law firm that handled the Andreu DPT case is also handling two of the test cases.

Here’s the full article by the National Law Journal.

 
Are you receiving TACA's regional newsletters with information on local TACA meetings and events? We can't send it to you if we don't know where you are! Please Join TACA (it's free) or update your membership to include your location. If you include your mailing address, you'll receive TACA's print newsletter, Talking Autism.

Talk About Curing Autism (TACA) provides general information of interest to the autism community. The information comes from a variety of sources and TACA does not independently verify any of it. The views expressed herein are not necessarily TACA’s. TACA does not engage in lobbying or other political activities.

go to home page